Ghost in the Shell
A question posed throughout all of human history, one possibly more insightful and more relevant than the meaning of life, deals with that of humanity. What makes a human being? Is it our body? Our intellect? Our consciousness? What makes man any different from a machine performing functions? Could a machine be more human than a human? The list goes on and on, and there’s still no definitive answer to the question— but it certainly gets us to think, doesn’t it? In 1995, an anime readdressed this question using cyborgs.
Science fiction often asks this question, among many other issues and questions it address, and popularly roots from the writings of Isaac Asimov. Ghost in the Shell, produced by Production I. G. in 1995, premiered, introducing us to the world where the line between human and machine is no longer distinct, and many people have upgraded to cybernetic bodies. We follow Major Motoko Kusanagi, of the security force Section 9, as she and her team track down a dangerous hacker known as the Puppet Master. At the same time, Kusanagi questions her existence as a cyborg and seeks to discover what it means to be truly human. Ghost in the Shell was a breakthrough in animation, blending cel and computer animation, as well as in the international arena, being among the first anime to be shown extensively in North America, and even being an influence for the Wachowski brothers in creating The Matrix. So, what makes it such a great film? Well, lets go over that in what will by my first essay of my Ghost in the Shell marathon:
The plot, adapted from the manga and made to fit into the length of a feature film, runs as a sort of typical cop/action movie; you’ve got your group of cops, your bad guy, throw in a few chase and fight scenes, and ultimately lead up to the climatic fight before resolving the conflict; oh, and your protagonist usually has some inner conflict to resolve by the end as well. Yeah, take all of this, add cyborgs, make it an anime, and you’ve got yourself Ghost in the Shell. However, the film does take a few twists of this story archetype, and makes a few liberties of its own, particularly with the ending, but also with a few of the scenes where it address the big question: what makes a human being?
The entire plot is pretty much a metaphor for this question, and there are scenes where they address it directly and where they address it very indirectly; the latter addressing is the more notable, and where composer Kenji Kawai gets to have the most fun. Sometimes the music within a scene is more than enough to deliver not only the emotion of the scene, but also to help get the audience to think about the big question, even without dialogue. The beautiful thing about it, though, is that neither the plot nor the human theme seem to be a second thought for the progression of the film; it doesn’t feel like the question was thrown into the plot at the end to appear smarter. Both the plot and this overarching theme are complementary to each other, and one would suffer without the other, resulting in the overall impact of the film to remain strong and intact.
The other amazing aspect of the movie which only complements the amazing plot and thematic elements is the animation. It’s a little dated now, but can still compete with a great deal of animation today. Like I stated earlier, Ghost in the Shell was among the first in anime to seamlessly blend cel and computer animation within a single work, next to such films as Macross Plus: Movie Edition. Other than that, it has that very raw, rough, 90s element to which makes it feel much more real, one of the areas in which a lot of animation today seems to fall short in.
Lastly, the characters seal the deal in creating the world of Ghost in the Shell. It’s difficult to capture important character elements in a feature length film, especially when adapting those characters from much longer works; in this case, a manga. The Ghost in the Shell film manages to keep all these characters true to their originals while cutting out a great deal of development. It doesn’t bore you with explaining why the characters are why they are, and instead shows you through their actions (another element that is disappearing modern animation). In fact, it does this with the not only the characters, but with the setting as well; when thrust into this alien world of cybernetics, brain hacking, and secret agencies, you’d expect a modern anime to give you a prologue to explain it. This, in true 90s fashion, ignores your questions and lets you think about it for yourself while it shows you; it does this with the characters too, which really elevates the experience as a viewer.
Overall, Ghost in the Shell is a masterpiece of science fiction animation. The plot handling, the thematic issues, the animation, the characters, and the truly 90s style of doing things all work together symbiotically. A must-see for all anime and science fiction fans alike, though not entirely suited for children due to adults themes and brief nudity. Ghost in the Shell easily deserves a 9/10, and is a great way to start my Ghost in the Shell marathon, where I will be viewing and reviewing the entire Ghost in the Shell anime franchise (since I need to anyways). Until my review of Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, I’ll see you around!
Mac Colestock 8:24 pm on January 8, 2011 Permalink |
Oshii’s film adaptation of Shirou’s manga is barely even an adaptation. It’s probably best to consider them two different beasts altogether due to how drastically they differ, but that’s not to say either one is bad. Aside from visual models, the characters aren’t even recognizable; the thought provoking but loose and lighthearted tone of the manga is contrasted by the somber, introspective, and melancholy tone of the film; and not to mention how the whole narrative had to be compressed and rewritten to the point of only bearing passing resemblance to its source material. But they’re both excellent, since Shirou works well with the comic format and Oshii’s adaptation–though wild in its liberties–does it justice while still remaining thoroughly “Oshii”. He only loses track of himself with Innocence, but… oh well.
The animation in that film is godly, too. Production IG certainly never fails to deliver on that front.
Sachi 8:36 pm on January 8, 2011 Permalink |
Ah, the difference in tone is one thing I forgot to mention. The 1995 film certainly is much, much more serious than the manga, and rightfully so. I personally like the seriousness this film has, and is one of the many reasons I enjoy it more than Stand Alone Complex, but that essay can be saved for another day.
juliancan 11:25 am on January 9, 2011 Permalink |
Extremely well-written article. Quite an amazing feat considering your age :D. I will be posting this article on Facebook with the hope that your number of viewers will increase thus gaining the recognition you rightfully deserve.
Indeed, the philosophy presented in this anime is quite interesting too and your essay about how humane is a human is quite intriguing and does justice to the anime series itself. Good job :D.
Other than that it is so weird, we have one year of difference but we are born on the same month and on the same day o.O. Both born on June 2nd. How did I acquire this information, by stalking your MAL account ;D:
Sachi 11:45 am on January 9, 2011 Permalink |
Wow, that is really weird. o.O
I’m glad you enjoyed the article. 😀 I tried to spice up my style a little bit with this one, while still following the same basic formula I’ve been developing over the last several months. It’s good to know that it’s been working.
Thank you for plugging my blog, as well! I’ll be sure to do the same for yours!
juliancan 10:41 pm on January 9, 2011 Permalink |
Anyways if you like anime series with a intriguing and convoluted plotline, having a lot of metaphors and symbolism hidden in it and of course a lot of depth, then I strongly suggest you to watch Monster and Honey and Clover. While Honey and Clover presents the whole philosophy surrounding the transition from adolescent to adulthood, Monster presents the danger of making a person miss his own childhood as well as teenhood, leaving him in an eternal deadlock of transition between his young years and his adult years. While Honey and Clover’s cast of characters are foolhardy college students, in Monster, the main interaction revolves around a life-saver– a doctor– and his pseudo creation, a young psychopath who has been trained to become the next Hitler.
http://myanimelist.net/anime/19/Monster
http://myanimelist.net/anime/16/Honey_and_Clover (the synopsis here does not do justice to its plot :/).
PS: Watched Yumekui Merry yet?
Sachi 10:55 pm on January 9, 2011 Permalink |
Monster has been on my list of things to watch forever, and I’ve been meaning to get to it for a while. Perhaps after I finish my Ghost in the Shell marathon. As for Honey and Clover: I’ve heard of it, but I’ve never actually looked into it. It was bound to get onto my list at some point, though, and I may get to watching it soon based off of your recommendation.
And yes, I did watch Yumekui Merry. It seems enjoyably silly, and I love the animation. I will certainly keep watching as the season goes on.
juliancan 4:06 am on January 12, 2011 Permalink |
LoL. Look at this! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVhggGSjXVg
It has GitS written all over it xP.
marinasauce 10:53 pm on January 16, 2011 Permalink |
Though I’ve never seen or read any of the Ghost in the Shell works, I did find your article intriguing and well-written. You have a pretty good hook, with the list of questions and draw to the average reader’s curiosity about humanity, that also transitions quite easily into your discussion of the 1995 anime rendition. I’ll have to get around to watching this sometime soon >.<
Marina 8:24 pm on June 9, 2011 Permalink |
I just wanted to drop by and let you know that I finally got around to watching this…and I loved it! Now I just need to get my hands on the 2nd film 🙂 Thanks for convincing me to watch it.